Amish peanut butter was commonly served at after-church lunches, and it frequently showed up at wedding and funeral lunches as well. My siblings and I would gladly skip the various assortment of jams and jellies if we could have some sweet Amish peanut butter!
This Amish apple pie has a beautiful buttery crust with just the right amount of flakiness. The hint of caramel in this filling adds a subtle richness, making this apple pie stand out from its competitors.